In Mexico alone there has been an estimate of 48 deaths of journalist since December of 2006. Each year the number of murders increase and do not include the kidnapped and tortured journalist in Mexico. Media protection laws have been overrun by shady governments and increasing violence in the country. Because media is often influenced by nations close by, the issues in Mexico have been ignored and offset for many years.
Saturday, March 30, 2013
Introduction
The Central America region is known in terms of media freedom worldwide as the second most open with freedom to the 15 countries in the area. Being so close to America, that does not surprise many. Although worldwide the Americas have become known as "free" in relations to media, they have become a deadly battlefield to journalist, especially in Mexico.
Friday, March 29, 2013
Brief Overview of Victims
Although Mexico is part of North America, they are part of the Central America regional designation. Mexico has faced many different struggles as a country for years. One struggle that has continued to rise is the murders of journalist. Since 1992 28 journalists have been murdered for a clear motive.
Examples:
Adrián Silva Moreno - November 2012
Moreno and his companion were shot to death after covering a story on theft and witnessing an incident between a soldier and civilian. Moreno covered local crime for various local newspapers.
Maria Elizabeth Macías Castro - September 2011
Macías's body was found decapitated on a road with a note that she was killed because of her work with social media related to a criminal group. Macías s death was the first documented worldwide in relation to social media. Macías worked with a pseudonym to protect herself while covering crime on the internet.
Luis Emanuel Ruiz Carrillo - March 2011
Ruiz was a college student photographer working with culture in a daily newspaper. Ruiz was kidnapped the night before his murder along with an entertainment show host and his cousin. All three were found with gunshot wounds to the head. Ruiz was covering a major drug cartel.
Bradley Will - October 2006
Will was a U.S. independent activist journalist who recorded his own death. Will was covering an incident between activist and anti-government group. In the middle of the conflict Will was shot and killed.
Thursday, March 28, 2013
Literature Review
After reading my literature I found myself searching for three main things pertaining to the issue of murders of journalist in Mexio:
1. Why were journalist targeted and what were they covering that lead to their murder?
2. What types of media laws does Mexico have to protect journalist?
3. Is anything being done to end this war against journalist?
- In an online database, Committee to protect journalist, countries were divided up to show all the statistics regarding journalist in the country. Mexico was provided with this chart.
1. Why were journalist targeted and what were they covering that lead to their murder?
2. What types of media laws does Mexico have to protect journalist?
3. Is anything being done to end this war against journalist?
- In an online database, Committee to protect journalist, countries were divided up to show all the statistics regarding journalist in the country. Mexico was provided with this chart.
The highest rate of journalist that were murdered were covering crime. Another chart on the database showed that the journalist murdered were print reporters and predominantly local reporters.
- In the article Mexico: Journalist Killed in Mexico Media Rights Groups are trying to make aware that since 2005 eight journalists have disappeared who were mostly covering government corruption and or organized crime.
-In the book, War on Words, a comment from Mogens Schmidt, Deputy Assistant Director-General for Communication and Information and Director of the Division of Democracy and Peace at UNESCO stated;
"Defining conflict environments is a very delicate and very difficult issue. Take the one number that really pushed the overall numbers forward last year -- the killing in the Philippines as a conflict area or not? We normally define it as a non-conflict area, while we do know that in the southern islands, especially in Mindanao, there is a lot of conflict going on and there is a very strong tension there. You can also take Mexico or Honduras, two countries with a relatively high number of journalists being killed over the last two years. Is Honduras a conflict area? Well, maybe you would define it as that after the trowing out of the former president and the whole unstable situation after that. And, Mexico -- is that a conflict area? No, it's not, but it's an area marred by very, very strong banditry groups, the drug cartels and that of course creates a terrible situation for the journalists. So, my point is that there is a growing problem with the killing of journalists; the targeted killing of journalists."
- In the Committee to Protect Journalist database revealed that the start of the attacks on journalist were between 1984- 1995 where 10 journalists were murdered for working with the publications of Zeta. Among the 10 murdered was the columnist and co-publisher of Zeta. The journalist reporting on criminal and political organizations are often murdered by those they are reporting on.
-In relation to the previous article a newspaper released the article, Ex Police Chief Held in Mexican Killing. The former chief surrendered and was held for covering up the murder of the countries best-know journalist who was murdered in 1984.
- In the article 'The Fragile State of Media Freedom in Latin America' gives an overview of the history of media freedoms in the Americas forming in the 1990s but has seen it reverse. In many cases of the journalist who were murdered, their cases turned into an example to scare away other journalist reporting on the same issues and for findings for the papers they worked for. In 2010 Mexico lost their media freedoms and has had an increase of violence since.
-In the article 'spate of attacks targets journalist in media' Inter American Press Association member, Ricardo Trotti said security is a growing issue in the Americas and has sent a letter to President Vicente Fox to get help from officials and investigations regarding crimes against journalist.
-Also from the article 'spate of attacks targets journalist in media' following an attack of a woman reporter who was badly injured after a shooting attack, police protection was given to two journalist.
- In the online article 'The Fragile State of Media Freedom in Latin America' some Central American countries are working on a 'reward' system for friendly media outlets with advertisements. By complying with the journalist and treating them well they are given advertising to promote themselves. Other countries, like Venezuela, the government has opened media for pro government messages.
-In the article UNESCO Condemns Murderers of Journalists in Mexico and Brazil in 2011 UNESCO demanded the killers of two journalists in the countries be punished. The Director-General, Irina Bokova, became concerned about the amount of women journalist being targeted and wanted to take action to bring it to an end. The article also brought attention to readers that families of journalists are also be targeted as victims.
- In the article Mexico: UN and Regional Experts Urge Government to Take Action to Protect Journalist Margaret Sekaggya, UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights defenders, stated in 2012, "Human rights defenders in Mexico desperately need the State's effective protection now... They continue to suffer killings, attack, harassment, threats, stigmatization and other serious human rights violations." The "Law for the Protection of Human Rights Defenders and Journalists" was passed which works to protect those at risk and work to protect others in the future.
- In online article Mexico Takes Big Step Forward in Protecting Professional and Citizen Journalists in 2012 Mexican Senate approved a constitutional amendment that federalizes criminal attacks on journalists so they would have authorities protecting them. The amendment states:
Federal authorities may also take cognizance of crimes in general jurisdiction, when these crimes are related to federal crimes or crimes against journalists, persons, or installations that damage, limit, or impair the right to information or the freedom of expression, or the press.
Wednesday, March 27, 2013
Discussion
So why should we care? With Mexico being so close to North America and Americans having more freedom to cross with media freedoms, Americans can enter the journalism warfare. Previously in an example, I posted a U.S. activist-journalist who was murdered in Mexico while covering his story. During a fight in Mexico involving other activist the journalist was shot and killed. His murder was also caught on his camera and was able to highlight the issues worldwide about the violence in Mexico and the problems journalist face while trying to report there.
Another issue could be American journalist reporting on crime and government in Mexico and returning to the U.S. and the crime coming into the U.S. The power that the gangs and government have over the journalists are more powerful and could easily come into the U.S. close to the border. America has many immigrants coming and going across its boarders and some could cause threats to journalists in the U.S. These threats can come not just from Mexico but from the other close countries facing media issues with their journalists. Of the 15 countries in Central America, only 43% are rated free. Because of these restrictions in their own countries, journalists in trouble could turn the the U.S. which could bring the same problems onto U.S. territory.
Another issue could be American journalist reporting on crime and government in Mexico and returning to the U.S. and the crime coming into the U.S. The power that the gangs and government have over the journalists are more powerful and could easily come into the U.S. close to the border. America has many immigrants coming and going across its boarders and some could cause threats to journalists in the U.S. These threats can come not just from Mexico but from the other close countries facing media issues with their journalists. Of the 15 countries in Central America, only 43% are rated free. Because of these restrictions in their own countries, journalists in trouble could turn the the U.S. which could bring the same problems onto U.S. territory.
Tuesday, March 26, 2013
Conclusion
In conclusion, there is a deeper story to Mexico's known problems of drug trafficking and government issues. Behind these problems lies murder of journalist trying to change the issues that are effecting Mexico. As more murders occurred and became a more know problem, law and amendments have been created to change the fates of some journalists trying to change the path that Mexico is currently taking. As the issues with murders in all countries makes people more aware they can help to not only bring justice to those who lost their lives because of evil gangs and shady government officials, but also bring protection to journalists of the future.
Monday, March 25, 2013
References
28 Journalists killed in Mexico since 1992/ motive confirmed. Committee to Protect Journalist. http://www.cpj.org/killed/americas/mexico/
Bernardo Ruiz on violence against Mexican journalists. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTWpW0bekfA
Branigin, William (1989, June 15). Ex-Police Chief held in Mexico killing. The Washington post (0190-8286) p.a.35.
Branigin, William (1989, June 13). Mexican writer's death laid to Ex-Police Chief; 1984 killing underlined journalists' plight. The Washington post (0190-8286), p. a.18.
Bright, Arther. (2012). Mexico takes a big step forward in protecting professional and citizen journalist. Digital Media Law Project.
Grillo, Ioan. (2006, Dec 8). Death of U.S. activist-journalist in Mexico highlights role of independent media. Associated Press, p.1.
Jordan, Mary. (2005). Spate of attacks targets journalists in Mexico. The Washington Post.
Karlekar, Karin Deutsch. (2012). The Fragile State of Media Freedom in Latin America. Freedom House.
Lisosky, Joanne M.; Henrichsen, Jennifer R. (2011). War on Words: Who Should Protect Journalists?.
McGuire, Michael. (1996, Mar 20). Deaths of journalists addressed. Chicago Tribune. (Pre-1997 Fulltext).
Mexico: UN and regional experts urge government to take action to protect journalists. (2012, May 15). M2 Presswire.
Mexico: Journalist killed in mexico. (2009, Dec 30). Asia News Monitor.
UNESCO condemns murderers of journalists in Mexico and Brazil. (2011, July 29). M2 Presswire.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







